Can Cats Eat Peanut Butter?

Can Cats Eat Peanut Butter?

Can cats eat peanut butter

@ Impact Photography / Adobe Stock

Most people are aware of the love that many animals have for peanut butter. Considering the amount of foods that may be harming them, however, can cats eat peanut butter?

Dogs, rodents and even birds appreciate the taste and the healthy fats. It’s only natural to wonder if you can share a spoonful of peanut butter with your feline friend.

We’re going to answer that question and give you the details on peanut butter for cats.

That way, you know whether or not sharing is a good choice. We’ll even cover some recipes your cat is sure to beg you for all day long!

Can Cats Eat Peanut Butter?

Cats are picky. There’s no question about that. You almost never know when they’re going to deny food or go crazy for it. Peanut butter is something that cats may feel either way about.

Some cats like peanut butter while others want nothing to do with it.

What’s important to note is that in either case, peanut butter isn’t something cats need in their diet. Because they are very strictly carnivores by nature, cats get all they need from meat.

That said, peanut butter is unlikely to hurt them if shared carefully and on rare occasions.

Cons Of Feeding Cats Peanut Butter

To begin with, cats often just aren’t fans of peanut butter. It’s a sticky substance that is in no way similar to meat.

As strict carnivores, cats don’t get anything from peanut butter. While it might be a useful resource for humans, it won’t provide any nutrition to our feline friends.

On top of that, there are a high number of calories in peanut butter. When used in moderation, this isn’t an issue for humans.

However, it becomes a problem much more quickly for cats. Cats typically only need around 200 calories on a daily basis.

This means that peanut butter isn’t a food you want to give your cat too often.

Pros Of Feeding Cats Peanut Butter

For cats that like the taste of peanut butter, it can be a nice rare treat. Think about peanut butter for cats like you would about ice cream, chips or candy for you.

They might taste nice, but they are often empty calories and are best consumed sparingly.

To aid in problems with the stickiness in peanut butter, you can cook the peanut butter into treats. That will mean fewer chances for your cat to choke.

You can also combine peanut butter with other ingredients that are better for them, such as fish.

Another way peanut butter can make itself useful is in hiding medications for your cat. We all know how hard it can be to get a cat to take a pill.

It’s often helpful to find a way to get them to eat it on their own. Peanut butter can aid in that solution.

What To Keep In Mind If You’re Going To Feed Your Cat Peanut Butter

No matter what treats your cat wants, you likely want to know how that yummy treat may affect their health. In some cases, you may not have thought of all the factors involved.

Consider The Calories

Think about the size difference between cats and humans. On average, human beings require about 2,000 calories a day.

On the other hand, cats only need about 200. In both cases, there are situations in which number adjustments are needed.

Now, let’s compare those numbers to the number of calories found in peanut butter. A typical serving of peanut butter is just a couple of tablespoons.

In these two tablespoons, there are 188 calories. That’s nearly all of the calories that a cat needs in a day.

On top of that, the calories cats get from peanut butter are empty. It would be like us having an entire gallon of ice cream in a single day.

Sure, it’s filling and tasty, but it does nothing for the body.

This is to pay special attention to when considering cats who are prone to being overweight. It’s only too easy to avoid adding even more calories to their diet by simply giving them a different kind of treat.

There are plenty of other choices that won’t overload them quite so much. Many would agree that it’s better to have a healthy cat who will hang around for a long time.

What’s In the Peanut Butter?

The ingredients in peanut butter aren’t always created equal. It’s one thing to add peanuts to your cat’s diet.

Sugars and hydrogenated oils are another story. Take a moment to consider what’s in your peanut butter before giving it to your cat.

You might find that you prefer a healthier option as well.

Instead of giving your cat a standard peanut butter, it’s better for them if you stick to brands that keep things simple. Organic, simple brands will leave the ingredients at peanut butter and a small amount of salt.

Keep in mind that cats don’t really need peanut butter at all. If you’re going to provide it to them anyway as a rare treat, it’s worth avoiding any unneeded ingredients that could be even less healthy for them to have.

Rare treats made with healthier peanut butter is the better choice.

Do You Really Want Your Cat To Have A Taste For It?

Peanut butter, by itself, isn’t toxic to your cat. It’s essentially junk food, but it’s not something that will poison them (unless they have an allergy). However, some uses for peanut butter may prove to be dangerous to your beloved pet.

Peanut butter is sometimes used to deliver poisons to pests. Rats, mice and other creatures find it to be a tasty snack.

On top of that, peanut butter is sticky. That means even touching the food can be a death sentence to these critters.

The same can be true for your cat if they manage to get into a rat trap.

If your cat is already a fan of peanut butter. you’ll need to be extra careful.

Make sure you’re their only resource for getting it. Don’t let them wander around outside without supervision.

Also, don’t use peanut butter as a poison delivery system in your own home. That way, your peanut butter-loving cat can stay as safe as possible.

Peanut Butter Recipes For Cats

Now that we know that cats can have peanut butter, here are several peanut butter, and non-peanut butter just in case, that are worth exploring. While there are only a few recipes out there, they might be all you need.

These treats cut down on the stickiness and make the fun last longer. Enjoy!

Apple Peanut Butter Treats

If your cat loves peanut butter, then they’re sure to enjoy these easy peanut butter treats. They only take around 20 minutes to make.

Also, the recipe will provide you with enough treats to last quite a while.

Apple Peanut Butter Treat Ingredients:

  • Quinoa Flour, ½ Cup
  • Buckwheat Flour, ½ Cup
  • Baking Soda, ¼ Tsp
  • Unsweetened Applesauce, ½ Cup
  •   Creamy Peanut Butter, ½ Cup

For the full instructions, you can take a look at the recipe here. Once you have them all baked up, feel free to give your cat a taste!

Even cats that aren’t usually a fan of peanut butter may enjoy these yummy treats.

You might even love them as well!

Sunflower Treats

These sunflower treats combine peanut butter with other tasty snacks like sunflower seeds, vegetables, apples, and oats. They make for a great treat that you might even enjoy!

Sunflower Treat Ingredients:

  • Flour, 2 Cups
  • Peas or Carrots (Cooked), ¼ Cup
  • Creamy Peanut Butter, 1 Cup
  • Molasses, 1 Cup
  • Sunflower Seeds, ¼ Cup
  • Apples (Skinned, Chopped), ½ Cup
  • Ground Oats, ¼ Cup
  • Rolled Oats, 1 Cup

Head over to for the full recipe! Don’t forget that this is a recipe that can work well for both cats and dogs.

If your cat doesn’t like some of the ingredients, feel free to leave them out. Not all cats are a fan of peas, carrots or apples.

Peanut Butter Treat Alternatives For Cats

If your cat doesn’t like peanut butter, or you want to offer them something else, these alternatives are great choices. Many of them involve foods that cats do get nutrition from, making them beneficial and enjoyable.

Salmon Treats

Salmon is obviously not even remotely close to peanut butter, but it contains a ton of healthy fat necessary for a healthy cat diet.

You can’t go wrong with salmon or other kinds of fish when it comes to cats. This easy treat recipe combines the things cats love to create treats they’ll go crazy for!

Salmon Treat Ingredients:

  • 1 Egg
  • Salmon, Canned – 10 Ounces
  • Whole Wheat Flour, 2 Cups

The Cookie Rookie covers this recipe in full, so head over there when you’re ready to mix it up! It’s well worth trying out.

The ingredients are minimal. They also don’t take a lot of time to make. Your cat is sure to be a big fan.

Catnip Treats

What cat doesn’t love their catnip? There’s no doubt that your cats will practically be jumping through rings of fire to get their paws on these treats.

Catnip Treat Ingredients:

  • 1 Egg
  • Wheat Germ, ¼ Cup
  • Wheat Flour, ¼ Cup
  • Catnip, ½ Tbsp
  • Canned Tuna, 5 Ounces
  • Flour, ½ Cup
  • Cornmeal, ½ Cup
  • Water, ¼ Cup

Catnip, tuna, and eggs are a recipe that your cat is going to enjoy. To take on this recipe, check out the full instructions at the MessForLess blog.

Just make sure that the tuna you choose is as fresh as possible. Also, avoid tuna that has too much sodium.

This is something cats love but should have in moderation. Canned fish can be a huge source of sodium, often too much.

Pumpkin Treats

Some cats may not be a fan of peanut butter, but they love pumpkin! Combining that pumpkin with some tasty sardines will surely result in some cat treats that they just can’t get enough of.

Pumpkin Treat Ingredients:

  • Canned Pumpkin (Make sure it’s organic), 1 Cup
  • Kelp, 1 Tbsp
  • Sardines (Without Bones Or Skin, Low-Sodium), 1 Cup
  • Fish Oil, 1 Tbsp

This recipe is courtesy of Chewy. If you aren’t familiar with Chewy, then it’s worth looking into!

Peanut Butter For Cats – Final Thoughts

Can cats eat peanut butter? Absolutely!

Although there are other better nutritional alternatives to your cat’s diet, peanut butter is essentially safe for them to eat. It isn’t toxic and most cats aren’t allergic to it.

On the other hand, peanut butter is high in calories and easy to choke on. It also doesn’t provide any nutrients to cats.

As a result, it’s probably not a bad idea to use something that does benefit cats instead.

That said, if your cat already loves peanut butter then it can’t hurt to give them a little bit of it once in a while. There are plenty of recipes you can use to create easy treats that are simple to make, store, and even easier to share!

As always, consult with your veterinarian if you have any concerns with your cat eating peanut butter!

The post Can Cats Eat Peanut Butter? appeared first on Quality Veterinarians Near You.

Comments are closed.